HR Management & Compliance

Navigating the Third Rail: Avoiding Discrimination Claims in Polarized Times

Controversial political topics can permeate workplace dynamics and escalate into litigation, especially during polarized times. An understanding of relevant laws and strategies for navigating these issues will help employers avoid costly consequences.

Background

Controversial global and political issues often affect workplaces, and mishandling communications surrounding those issues can lead to litigation. A recent Wall Street Journal report reveals how a counseling practice in Dallas encountered lawsuits, ruptured relationships, and loss of clients after poorly managing communications surrounding the October 7 attacks in Israel and war in Gaza.

About a year after the 2023 attacks in Israel, a non-Jewish therapist asked her two Jewish colleagues for advice on how to treat a Jewish client struggling with rising antisemitism. This discussion took place during a weekly meeting, where the group often discussed political issues and treatment of clients from different backgrounds. However, the owner of the practice, who is half-Palestinian, stated that the Jewish therapists’ advice would be unhelpful and one-sided, and left the meeting. She then sent out an email prohibiting further discussion of the Israeli/Palestinian conflict and political discussion in general, claiming the topic caused her personal pain. 

The Jewish therapists sent emails back to the team, claiming that neither Israel nor Palestine were brought up during the meeting, that the discussion of the Jewish experience in that context was not political, and that the cultural competence their colleague attempted to gain to help her client was one of the most important parts of their jobs. Shortly after, the two owners of the practice fired both Jewish therapists, who didn’t have any disciplinary history, stating they were no longer a good fit.

The two therapists initially received letters from the owners’ legal counsel demanding tens of thousands of dollars and threatening to prosecute noncompete agreements. The Jewish therapists subsequently filed a lawsuit alleging intentional discrimination against their Jewish identities and unlawful retaliation for opposing what they believed was workplace discrimination. They ultimately reached a confidential settlement, and the case was dismissed.

With upcoming elections and intense polarization in the current political climate, now is the time to learn how to properly navigate these matters. Understanding the legal framework surrounding protected activity, protected classes, and workplace communications can help you effectively handle these contentious topics in the workplace and avoid disastrous consequences.

Protected Activity and Protected Classes

While free speech is protected by the U.S. Constitution, that doesn’t mean anything goes in the workplace. You are allowed to restrict speech, so long as the rules are in line with local and federal laws, clearly communicated to employees, and applied consistently across all topics and employees.

An important aspect of the legal framework to understand is how protected activity interacts with unprotected conduct. Protected activity refers to employees taking steps to report, oppose, or investigate discrimination, harassment, and other practices in the workplace. The law protects such actions from retaliation. However, all workplaces have conduct that is not allowed and thus unprotected. When unprotected conduct interacts with controversial political topics, it’s important to separate conduct from ideologies.

Being aware of laws surrounding protected classes is also crucial. After contacting their lawyers, the co-owner of the Dallas counseling practice texted the other owner that “a minority is very, very difficult to fire,” in response to his question about “WTF” a protected class is. Under federal law, a protected class is a group of people protected from discrimination based on shared characteristics such as race, color, religion, sex, national origin, age, and disability. Terminating or punishing someone because any of these characteristics can lead to wrongful termination and discrimination lawsuits.

Managing Communications

As demonstrated in the Dallas case, understanding how to manage communications—especially those in the digital sphere—will help you avoid missteps. One major mistake the Dallas employers made was relying on unwritten rules regarding what type of political speech was allowed in the workplace and not applying the rules consistently. Had the rules been written, applied consistently for all political topics, and communicated to employees upon hiring, they could have avoided at least some of the mess they later encountered.

Another important thing to remember is that off-the-record communications over email, text, or other digital channels can be used as evidence. You should thus avoid discussing sensitive workplace topics through online forums.

Email, Slack, Teams, and other sites commonly used in workplaces can also lead to liabilities. Having rules in place for communications between employees and employers on these sites is useful, as well as documenting any misuse of those communication channels.

What Employers Should Do

Have written policies: Make sure employees are aware of any rules relating to speech and communications by providing them in written format and making them clear when onboarding employees.

Apply standards consistently: If employees aren’t allowed to discuss a specific political topic, then they shouldn’t be allowed to discuss any political topic, and vice versa.

Punish conduct, not ideologies: If workplace conflict based on political issues verges into unprotected conduct, ensure a separation of the employee’s conduct and ideology or identity.

Implement guidelines for digital communication: Avoid missteps over digital communications by having clear guidelines and training employees on communication hygiene.

Establish channels for escalation: Make sure employees have ways to escalate conflicts or address concerns so it’s less likely they will escalate through workplace communication channels. Consider having an open-door policy to allow a space for grievances.

Remember that digital forums are discoverable: Slack, Email, Teams, Zoom, and many other online platforms can be legally requested and used as evidence in lawsuits. Implement clear communication policies and have procedures in place to keep relevant digital records.

Bottom Line

Controversial political issues are, at times, unavoidable, but they don’t have to expose employers to risk. If you are informed about employment laws and follow the actionable steps above, you can evade damaging conflict and litigation.

Jacob M. Monty is an attorney with Monty & Ramirez LLP in Houston and can be reached at jmonty@montyramirezlaw.com. 

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *