A few years ago, I called a reference for a candidate who’d sailed through every round of interviews. The reference confirmed dates of employment and said the candidate was “a pleasure to work with.” I hung up 15 minutes later having learned nothing I didn’t already know.
That call didn’t cost anything in the moment. But multiply it across every requisition in a mid-size or large organization, and it’s a compounding problem. Candidates pick their own references. Questions stay surface-level. Former employers, worried about their own liability, default to vague positivity. The result is a screening step that rarely changes a hiring decision.
AI has changed the math on that. It’s easier than ever for a candidate to dress up their résumé and performance beyond what they can back up. In a 2025 survey of 3,000 hiring managers, 59% said they’ve suspected a candidate of using AI to misrepresent themselves during the hiring process, and only 19% said they’re extremely confident their current process would catch a fraudulent applicant. A reference—someone who’s actually worked alongside the candidate—is one of the few checks left that’s hard to fake.
The price of getting this wrong keeps climbing, too. SHRM’s most recent recruiting benchmark puts the average cost of a non-executive hire at roughly $5,500 and an executive hire at nearly $36,000. Reference checks are one of the cheapest tools an organization has to avoid paying that cost twice. Most just aren’t using them well.
Why the Reference Check is an HR Leadership Problem
For years, the advice on fixing this pointed at the person making the call: Ask sharper questions, listen closer, and don’t take the easy answer at face value. But ask 10 hiring managers at the same company how they run a reference check, and you’ll get 10 different approaches—different questions, different follow-ups, and a different sense of what’s even worth writing down afterward.
Fixing this means building the parts of the process that don’t exist yet: a standard, a way to catch what gets missed, and a record of what was said. Here’s where to start:
- Standardize the question set. When every hiring manager improvises, the process is inconsistent by definition, and that’s exposure waiting to happen if a hiring decision gets challenged. Give every candidate the same reference check, and treat the question set like the assessment tool it actually is.
- Train hiring managers to sit in the silence. A pause on a reference call is data, but most hiring managers are trained to fill silence, not sit in it. A short training module fixes this faster than you’d think.
- Write it down. Require a few lines of notes after every call covering what was asked, what was said, and whether anything gave the caller pause. That record protects the organization if a decision is questioned later, and it keeps reference data from evaporating after one 15-minute call.
What the Standard Should Include
Once the process is standardized, what’s on the question set still matters. Two questions reliably surface more than “would you recommend them” ever does, and both belong in the standard set HR puts in place:
1. What advice would you give this person’s next manager?
It’s a stranger, smaller question than references expect, and that’s exactly why it belongs on the list. It asks the reference to be useful rather than just complimentary, and that’s usually where a real management quirk or growth area comes out. A question about strengths would never get there.
2. What’s a specific example of a time this person had to deliver hard feedback, own a mistake, or navigate a disagreement?
Research on reference check validity has found that fewer than 1% of references ever rate a candidate as below average. Judgment calls like “Is this person a strong leader?” are easy to answer with a compliment. A request for a specific memory is harder to fake on the spot. It also shows how someone behaves when something goes wrong, which the glowing first few minutes of a call rarely reveal, and it gives HR something concrete to compare against what the candidate said in the interview. The stakes are real: Employees already spend an average of 2.8 hours a week dealing with workplace conflict, so a screening process that skips this question risks adding to that number instead of easing it.
Same Call, Better Outcome
A better reference check doesn’t take longer than a bad one. The same 15-minute call produces very different information depending on whether there’s a standard behind it and whether the right questions are being asked. What changes the outcome is whether HR treats this step like any other part of a defensible hiring process: standardized, trained, and documented, no matter who’s making the call that day. With AI making it easier than ever for candidates to dress up what they’ve actually done, the reference check may be one of the last steps in the process that still depends on a real person answering a real question.
Marti Carr is the President of Digital Marketing Recruiters, a specialized firm dedicated to matching talented digital marketing professionals with growth-focused businesses. With a rich background in digital marketing, Marti has spent over a decade refining her expertise in talent acquisition, business process architecture, and leadership development.

