We frequently get questions about how to conduct a proper investigation of a claim of workplace discrimination or harassment. Of course, we have suggestions (basing questioning around the five W’s: who, what, when, where, and witnesses; getting the complaint’s story committed to writing; etc.). But sometimes lessons can best be learned from the carnage of an investigation gone awry. And things went horribly wrong in a case coming out of Philadelphia. The investigation was truly a house of horrors!

Cautionary Tale
Here’s the scary campfire story:
Two police officers working for the city of Philadelphia alleged sexual harassment and sexual assault by their supervisor.
One officer claimed she was sexually assaulted in the supervisor’s police car. An inspection of the car found physical evidence that some sexual activity had occurred, and when confronted, the supervisor admitted he had engaged in sexual activity in the car with a “civilian woman” but not the complaining police officer. The city took the supervisor’s word for it and never asked for the name of the civilian. The investigator never followed up to ask the “civilian” whether the supervisor’s recounting of his extracurricular activities with her was, in fact, true.
Scary lesson no. 1: Always ask the follow-up question! Simply taking the alleged harasser’s story at face value, and not even trying to corroborate it, isn’t in Chapter 1 of “How to Conduct a Good Workplace Investigation.” Ask the follow-up questions. Try to get corroboration. This is true of all alleged facts uncovered during a workplace investigation, whether asserted by the alleged victim, the alleged harasser, or any witnesses.
Don’t Transfer Complainant
The second officer claimed the supervisor made a litany of inappropriate, sexual comments and sexually assaulted her in the supervisor’s office. In response, the city transferred her to a different shift, one that was difficult for her because her mother was unable to provide child care during the newly assigned shift. The police department captain, who made the decision to transfer the complaining officer, admitted to a subordinate that he was transferring her because she made the complaint!
Scary lesson no. 2: Don’t transfer the complainant to a different shift or otherwise alter the terms and conditions of employment in response to a complaint. The alleged victim and alleged harasser should always be separated during the pendency of an investigation, but don’t do so by switching shifts or otherwise changing employment terms and conditions. That’s a surefire way to invite a claim of unlawful retaliation.
Investigate Thoroughly
The city finally decided to investigate the claims but did an unsatisfactory job. Multiple people investigated the allegations, so there was no continuity in the investigation. The investigators failed to reach out to anyone outside the police department to ask questions even though it was apparent there were multiple witnesses with important information who didn’t work for the police department. And finally, the investigators failed to investigate, at all, one of the complainant’s claims of retaliation.
Scary lesson no. 3: Be thorough in your investigation, and use only one fact investigator. As discussed above, asking the victim and each witness “Who did what, when did they do it, where did they do it, and are there witnesses?” is a good start to ensure your investigation is thorough. And try to reach out to all witnesses who may have relevant information. Even if those people no longer work for your company and refuse to talk, making the effort to reach out is important.
Sean A. Monson is a shareholder with Parsons Behle & Latimer and can be reached at 801-532-1234 or smonson@parsonsbehle.com.
